The core problem with crowdsourced salary sites is selection bias: only certain types of workers share their compensation. Research consistently shows that high earners — particularly in tech — are dramatically overrepresented on Glassdoor, Levels.fyi, and similar platforms. The workers who post their salaries are disproportionately in major metro areas, at name-brand companies, and have salaries worth sharing. The result is figures that can be 20–40% above what most workers in a given title actually earn.
How BLS Collects Its Data
The BLS Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics program avoids this problem by surveying employers directly. The May 2024 release drew from approximately 1.1 million employer establishments across all industries, producing wage estimates that are statistically representative of actual employment. Methodology, sample sizes, and confidence intervals are all publicly documented and peer-reviewed — transparency that no crowdsourced platform can match. In states that participate in mandatory reporting, response rates exceed 75%.
Limitations to Know
That said, BLS data has its own limitations. It reflects base wages only — bonuses, equity, and benefits are excluded. It’s also published with an 18-month lag (May 2024 data was collected through May 2024 and released in late 2024), so it may understate salaries in rapidly growing fields. And the occupation groupings are broad enough that a “software developer” ranges from a junior web developer to a principal engineer. These limitations are real and worth understanding.
How to Use Both Data Sources
The right approach is to use BLS data as your floor — the reliable baseline — and supplement it with role-specific market data when negotiating for a specific position. BLS tells you where the market actually is; Levels.fyi or recruiter intel tells you where the ceiling is for your specific title and company tier. In salary negotiations, BLS is the defensible anchor. When evaluating offers, the more granular sources help you calibrate whether an offer is truly competitive for your exact situation.